Youth, and Local Government, is wasted on the young – Part 1

Would she want a job in Local Government?

At Welovelocalgovernment we have a mix of professions and backgrounds. Therefore, when one of us suggested writing a piece about the plight of young people in the local government workforce we decided to do it in two bits; part 1 about young people with a graduate background and part 2 about young people without a graduate background. This is Part 1.


I had a meeting with someone in HR the other day (unfortunately, meetings with HR nowadays tend to involve discussing the redundancy process) but before I left we had a brief chat about the age profile of local authorities.

There may be some exceptions but in my experience local authorities seem to be populated by those of us firmly rooted in middle age, if not slightly slipping into the ‘wise elder’ category. It makes me wonder how they all got here; surely these people were young once? If not, when did they join Local Government?

The central civil services certainly does not have this problem; the Fast Stream is almost famous in terms of a graduate scheme and brings through a steady stream of excellent university students, gives them five years protected tenure within the Civil Service and then lets them loose within the higher levels of the civil service. As I understand it the fast stream brings in at least 500 graduates per year who can then work their way through the management grades.

In Local Government we have a few equivalents. New accountants can join and take their accountancy qualifications and the same tends to apply to lawyers and social workers and other ‘professional’ jobs. The generalists are covered by a relatively new National Graduate Development Programme (NGDP) which maybe brings in 120 graduates across the sector.

However, a recent post by ‘MattSkinner1986’ on the Guardian Local Government Network illustrated the problems that exist with this scheme; namely that local authorities don’t seem to value their talented young graduates in the same way as the Civil Service and aren’t even trying to protect them (apparently only 1 in 5 of this year’s intake have permanent employment).

It seems that even where local authorities have young people working for them these same young people are not necessarily seen as ‘crucial’ to the future of the local authority in the way the fast streamers are for the Civil Service.

So why is this? Local Government does seem to prefer experience over innovation; knowledge over skills and organisational history over new ideas. This leads to employers focusing on those they can ‘trust’ to know how the organisation works and ‘hit the ground running’ rather than take the risk on a younger unproven member of staff.

Equally, there are less ways into these organisations. Graduate schemes don’t always exist and where they don’t, the ‘entry level’ jobs are very difficult to access as a job that may be entry level for a graduate is also something a housing officer has been working ten years to access.

The flip side of this is that graduates tend not to be willing to start doing more menial work to work their way up to get a chance. There are plenty of private sector options out there that are more interesting and probably pay more whilst also allowing the ambitious to move on more quickly.

The second problem is illustrated by ‘MattSkinner1986’ above. He loves his job but says tellingly:

‘I really enjoy my role as a full-time officer in an inner London Council at the moment, I have lots of ideas about how to improve the sector and I enjoy the feeling of making a difference to local communities. I want to develop a career in the public sector but even for me the pull of the private sector is hard to ignore.’

If you are young and overcome the above barriers and get into Local Government and develop some skills why would you stay? The things that Local Government ‘sell’ as the most important reasons to join do not necessarily apply to younger people; pensions, flexible working hours, annual leave entitlements and job security (?!?) do not interest a generation that are willing, and indeed keen, to move jobs fairly regularly. The things that matter to the young are the chance to ‘make a difference’, the opportunity to innovate and probably the chance to make quick career progress (not something Local Government promotes).

Maybe this leads to younger people leaving local government to progress their career, have big ideas, try new things and feel empowered before they then return to local government when the lure of pensions etc start to matter more.

If I am right (a big ‘if’), and if these beneficial conditions of employment are about to be reduced (a lot of authorities are considering matching the private sector) then surely it is crucial that Local Authorities address the young person issue quickly.

Not offering contracts to 4/5ths of the people on their graduate scheme is not the way to start.

Explore posts in the same categories: The future of Local Govt

Tags: , , , , ,

You can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.

5 Comments on “Youth, and Local Government, is wasted on the young – Part 1”

  1. hausfrau Says:

    This definitely rings very true with my local authority. I’m nearing the end of the NGDP with my local authority and have entered redeployment. Rather than look at my skill-set (that the council has spent considerable resources investing in), HR seem determined to only allow me access to jobs that match the salary that I have been on, which in the case of my local authority are administrative assistant posts. As I have repeatedly explained, this was a training salary and does not reflect the level that I have worked at in the organisation. There seems to be no interest in keeping me on – I’m highly disposable because I am young and cheap- rather than thinking of what I can add to an organisation. I’ve seen many older and pretty incompetent staff kept during restructures where young and capable staff are got rid off and it’s extremely hard not to feel disillusioned. I’m resigned to the fact that I will be leaving local government in the Spring and no matter how hard I work this will make no impact on being able to stay.

  2. […] on November 20, 2010 by disruptiveinnovators A recent post on the WeLoveLocalGovernment blog highlighted the issues faced by young local government officers as the cuts to local authorities […]

  3. […] readers will no doubt have read a piece by a co-blogger last week, which made the point that local government is dominated by old people and that younger, more energetic and less fearful staff find it too difficult to get in on the […]

  4. […] true as the financial pressures mount, and older, more experienced staff leave to be replaced by young, less experienced but sharp and keen staff who’s careers are more before than behind […]

  5. […] be able to find employment in local government, before taking a look at the graduates in question through two different pieces.  We think graduates are a good thing by the way, even if sometimes we rant about […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: