The abolition of the Audit Commission

It was announced on Friday that the Government wanted to abolish the Audit Commission.

Many in Local Government were outraged; some argued that the Audit Commission was already a lean organisation that was delivering a very efficient service (Heather Wakefield from Unison); others argued that the Audit Commission provided a public sector audit service which would be impossible to achieve in the private sector; and the Chairman of the Audit Commission pointed out that it had “more than fulfilled” the goals set out for it.

I did not shed a tear. The Audit Commission had become a tool of terror wielded by overweening central Government against supposedly recalcitrant local authorities. However, that was not all it did. The AC developed policy, lobbied the Government on behalf of local Government, produced best practice guides and Value for Money tools, audited performance and effectiveness as well as accounts and developed funky websites that no-one would read (see oneplace).

In summary, the Audit Commission grew and grew, taking on more powers and responsibilities and finding ways to have a role in whichever new policy the Government of the day wanted to pursue. With this came well paid Chairmen, communications officers and all the trappings of the modern QUANGO; all paid for by the public purse. How much of their budget was actually spent on auditing the accounts of local authorities I can only guess.

So yes, I welcome the general tenet of the announcement by Mr Pickles.

However, and this is a big however, does the medicine fit the disease? Yes, the Audit Commission was pursuing the wrong aims but simply hiving audit work off to the private sector may not be the long-term solution local authorities need.

As I see it Mr Pickles had two choices.

1) He could have simply stopped the Audit Commission from doing all of the other work it currently did and return it to being a public sector auditor. This would probably have saved most of the full £50 million Mr Pickles has identified and maintain a valuable public sector audit resource.

2) He could abolish the Audit Commission and privatise local government audit.

Short term option 2) is probably easier and looks simpler. Unravelling a behemoth like the Audit Commission would have been a pain and would have taken time. However, privatising audit will probably end up increasing costs for local authorities; not in real terms but over what it would have cost had the Audit Commission stuck to auditing. In addition, private providers will not have the public accountability that the Audit Commission did.

In 5-10 years I bet that some future Government will decide to invent a small public sector body that can provide cheaper cost audit to local authorities; in fact local authorities might even work together to create one themselves.

I commend Mr Pickles for making a tough decision to abolish the Audit Commission but am afraid that he has also ducked the tougher option of reforming the Audit Commission and providing the sort of public sector audit we all need.

Explore posts in the same categories: The future of Local Govt

8 Comments on “The abolition of the Audit Commission”

  1. localgov Says:

    For a public sector worker I’m surprisingly private sector in much of my thinking, but I can’t see the full benefit of this move. Like you, I think they should have stripped it back Ronseal-style, making it just do exactly what it says on the tin.

    This is going to end up costing public sector big time in the long-term, whether in financial costs or other.

  2. […] written about some hot topics on this blog, from the abolition of the audit commission to the abolition of the NHS via the abolition of common sense when using ‘reply […]

  3. […] we have discussed before, the government recently announced that the mighty Audit Commission would be no more.  It would […]

  4. […] more to truly understand whether our authorities are spending correctly… If only we had a commission of some sort to audit local […]

  5. […] lots of good stuff in there.  The changes to the Audit Commission set-up which we have ourselves looked at before way back in 2010 are worth unpicking further at some stage and proposals around the Draft Care […]

  6. […]  Soon after we went against the then-current grain and didn’t get upset when the Audit Commission went away, and we started seeing some silver lining appearing in the growing economic crisis facing local […]

  7. It does appear, however, that hypnosis can help a person achieve his or her weight loss goals.
    Anyone who dares to make a closer inspection will find the
    underlying difference. That way, the actual process will end up
    being much less frustrating and, for the majority of people, enjoyable.

  8. Quentin Says:

    a Bruce Lee workout includes stretching, bending, running, dipping,
    kicking, jumping, traditional muscle building exercises,
    weight lifting, rope skipping, medicine ball handling, etc.
    Vitamin B3 or also called as Niacin is important in weight
    loss because it is responsible for the regulation of thyroid hormones and also
    in sugar levels in the body. Do not be tempted to lose weight as quickly as you can,
    because a crash diet will have you eating less than a thousand calories
    a day slowing down your metabolism.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: